Season 11: Hits & Misses

I share my Hits & Misses of When Calls the Heart Season 11.

Hearties! We made it through another season of When Calls the Heart! I want to share my hits and misses of each storyline. It has been a while since I shared a post about Season 11 of When Calls the Heart but I wanted to take my time. I have had some time to process the season and gather my thoughts. So here are my hits and misses of Season 11.

Disclaimer: I don’t expect everyone to share the same opinion as I do. I enjoyed the season as a whole but there were some parts that I didn’t like as much as others.

Hallmark Media, LLC

Nathan & Elizabeth

Overall I would consider this storyline a huge hit! Nathan & Elizabeth revisited some heavy topics from their past, and with extra support from one another, they moved forward as a team. A job well done by the writers for revisiting important storylines such as Allie’s father, the return of Tom Thornton, and Mr. Landis’s unyielding obsession with Elizabeth. I would consider these the Top 3 Nathan & Elizabeth storylines of Season 11. A different hard topic was highlighted in these Top 3 storylines. This requires them to work together as a team to move forward. They tackled grief, parental abandonment, sexual harassment, and abuse of power. As a result, they became stronger as a couple romantically and as almost co-parents.

However, even the Nathan & Elizabeth storyline has some shortcomings. But that’s perfectly fine! Unfortunately, the pacing and timing of their relationship in Season 11 were major misses this season. I was never expecting them to get engaged or married. However, the trepidation and continued lack of communication after Episode 6 was a detrimental decision and impacted my overall enjoyment of the season. I was frustrated to see them fall back into their old habits of not communicating their feelings. And when they did, it seemed like an afterthought such as Elizabeth telling Nathan “Friends don’t look at friends that way” in the last 30 seconds of Episode 6. I hoped this was this episode, especially her words, would be the catalyst for moving their relationship forward. Sadly, it was not, and it seems things started to go backward until Episodes 8 and 11.

Nathan & Allie

Nathan & Allie continue to be the one constant in the show I can always count on to make me smile. The bond and relationship between Nathan & Allie is beautiful to watch on screen. I loved seeing how protective they were of each other this season. In Season 11 we watched their bond get tested, stretched, and ultimately strengthened. Nathan & Allie continue to support and protect one another. I look forward to seeing their storyline in Season 12.

Mei & Mike

I’m likely in the minority but I enjoyed watching Mei and Mike’s relationship unfold. I will admit the relationship seemed rushed at times but ultimately I feel it was best to have them marry. I appreciate and enjoyed how Mei shared her culture unapologetically with Mike. In turn, Mike is receptive and eager to learn more about her family and culture.

Faith & Lily

A sweet addition to the season that pulled at my heartstrings. I am crossing my fingers for more of these in the future seasons. If I had one suggestion for this storyline I would say I wish it was more consistent throughout the episodes. It felt like this story was introduced and then dropped off for a few episodes before coming back in the last couple of episodes.

The Canfield’s

I enjoyed their story this season. Joseph’s story primarily focused on his reconciliation with his estranged brother. Minnie grappled with being a pastor’s wife and trying to have the right answer all the time. This is unrealistic but relatable because it’s realistic. Minnie and Joseph encourage one another through each of their trials. I loved this story because it highlights real-life issues and is a good example of healthy communication.

Rosemary & Bill’s Investigation

I loved this new pairing and the new storylines it created. Rosemary’s bubbly personality and journalistic skills paired with Bill’s investigative expertise made it fun to watch! Admittedly, I was frustrated with the power struggle in the beginning but they worked together beautifully and ultimately helped track down the criminals.

The Resort, Politics, & Lucas

I’ll be honest, I knew from the start this storyline was never going to come to fruition. It was disappointing because it felt like a “waste” of the storyline. I would have liked to see something similar or the resort built to create growth and new storylines. Unfortunately, with the halting of the resort and the new proposition of a National Park for Season 12, I don’t see how they can circle back to the resort. Lucas’s strengths are in politics so I don’t want to completely dash that idea. However, politics with a positive outcome would be nice. Politics is a slippery slope but this is Hope Valley so I think a little bit of embellishment is appropriate.

Jeanette Aucoin

Jeanette entered as a mysterious lady from Lucas’s past. As the season moved forward we learned she may have a hidden agenda. It turns out Jeanette is involved in some shady dealings and is the mastermind behind Casimir Shaw. I have mixed feelings about this storyline because Jeanette entered with such gusto and charisma. She was the perfect balance for Lucas’s character. I was hoping she would be the good guy in the end with hopes they would pursue the spark in Season 12. Redemption for Jeanette is not out of the picture but I think any hopes of a romance with Lucas are dashed for good.

Thank you for reading my Season 11 Hits & Misses. Although it is late I wanted to get this posted before sharing my Season 12 Hopes and Wishes. Stay tuned for that post!

Catch up on my latest When Calls the Heart posts!

Season 12 Questions & Predictions

The Ghost of Nathan Grant’s Past & Present

My Thoughts on Lucas & Jeanette

YOUR TURN! What are your Top 3 Hits & Misses for Season 11?